Fluffernutter
Peanut butter and marshmallow. Sandwich optional.
The sandwich you weren't supposed to have for lunch.
Creamy peanut butter ice cream swirled with pillowy marshmallow bits — the classic Fluffernutter sandwich reimagined as a super premium pint. Rich, roasty peanut butter leads the way, while soft marshmallow pieces deliver bursts of fluffy sweetness in every scoop. It's lunchbox rebellion, all grown up.
Why you'll love it
Every pint starts with Secret Creamery's proprietary six-ingredient, clean-label base: 16% butterfat, cream listed first, no corn syrup, and rBST-free milk. Churned with low overrun for a dense, velvety texture that lets the peanut butter shine. A throwback flavor built for anyone 30+ who remembers sneaking that peanut-butter-and-marshmallow sandwich — and for everyone discovering it for the first time.
The details
A true 16 oz pint of super premium peanut butter marshmallow ice cream, produced in an SQF-certified facility, packaged in low-plastic pint containers. From Secret Creamery of Las Vegas, Nevada — pints the freezer aisle forgot. Experience The Scoop™.
Shipping
Pints ship frozen with dry ice inside the continental US. Orders placed by noon PT ship Monday–Wednesday.